Mystery – Carol's Notebook

The Marlow Murder Club by Robert Thorogood

March 17, 2025March 17, 2025 by Carol6 Comments

I honestly expected to thoroughly enjoy The Marlow Murder Club. It features three very different women who form a friendship and solve murders. We have Judith, in her 70s, who lives on her own in a mansion on the edge of town, drinks too much, and sets crossword puzzles. Becks is the vicar's wife, who usually spends her time taking care of her family and house. Suzy is a dog-walker who is estranged from her adult daughter. I like the friendship the women form and how they push each other outside of their comfort zones. The plot is where the story really let me down. Judith very early on has a couple of suspicions and then they spend the rest of the book trying to prove her theories. A few of the clues were unbelievable. The twist wasn't surprising, although it did make the mystery overly convoluted. Even the suspenseful ending was over the top and borderline silly. I listened...

Bodies and Battlements by Elizabeth Penney

March 14, 2025March 14, 2025 by Carol1 Comment

Bodies and Battlements is the first in a new cozy mystery series. Ravensea Castle has recently been converted into a Bed and Breakfast and they are welcoming their first guests. Everything is going fine-ish until a local woman is found murdered in the garden and the Asquith family, guests and staff become potential suspects. Nora has potential to be a great character. She's determined to keep the castle in the family by making the B&B a success. She also grows herbs and flowers in the garden that she makes into lotions, soaps, etc. She is sane and solid, in the midst of her actress sister, eccentric father, quirky staff, and resident ghost, but that does make her seem a little boring. We do have the start of a romance that might be fun, but it's with a cop, which I'm a little tired of. The setting is fabulous - the castle, the town, the seashore. And the pets - two cats and...

The Mysterious Mr. Quin by Agatha Christie

March 12, 2025March 12, 2025 by CarolNo Comments

The Three Act Tragedy led me to a reread of The Mysterious Mr. Quin, collection of short mystery stories that feature Mr. Harley Quin and Mr. Satterthwaite. Mr. Satterthwaite, is upper class, single, a man who loves his comforts and is rich enough to afford them. He enjoys life’s dramas, watching rather than participating. Satterthwaite is both the main character and the sidekick. It’s his reasoning and actions that solve the mysteries, but it’s Harley Quin who mysteriously shows up at just the right time and asks just the right questions. Mr. Quin is a touch supernatural, he seems to intercede on the behalf of lovers or the dead, those whose mysteries still need solved. The stories in the collection are a variety of situations. Sometimes cold cases are solved, tragedy prevented because a wrong is righted, and sometimes a murder is solved. I think I enjoyed them more this time around because I knew what to expect. I listened to...

Three Act Tragedy by Agatha Christie

March 11, 2025March 12, 2025 by CarolNo Comments

Three Act Tragedy is not a story I remember well - it's been ages since I read it last. This time around I listened to the audiobook, narrated by Hugh Fraser, who just does these wonderfully. His characterizations are spot on and his pace and tone match the plot well. The book opens with a dinner party. A retired famous actor, Sir Charles Cartwright, hosts a dinner party for local friends and some guests from London including Mr. Satterthwaite (from the Harley Quin stories) and Hercule Poirot. Of course, someone dies, but only Sir Charles and another guest, the young Miss Egg Lytton-Gore suspect suspect murder. Until a second house party with many of the same guests ends in a similar death, but this time it's definitely murder - the police discover the poison that was used. Sir Charles and Egg convince Satterthwaite and eventually Poirot that they need to take the investigation into their own hands. The plot is...

The Secret Detective Agency by Helena Dixon

March 5, 2025March 5, 2025 by Carol3 Comments

The Secret Detective Agency has a good set up. We're in London in 1941, right in the middle of WW2. Jane Treen, a mid level spymaster working in Whitehall, is concerned because several of her agents who were connected with Operation Exodus have been murdered. There seems to be a mole in their midst. Most recently, Kate Trevellian was murdered in a small village outside of Exeter, at Half Moon Manor, the home of Arthur Cilento. Arthur, conveniently, is a mathematician and codebreaker who also works for the government. Arthur had been renting the house out to Kate, and he has just returned home, so is not a suspect. Jane's boss sends her to Half Moon Manor to work with Arthur to figure out who murdered Kate and uncover the plot to kill off the remaining Operation Exodus spies. Jane and Arthur are total contrasts to each other. Jane is intuitive, on the move, and a chain-smoker (as we are...

Murder in an Irish Garden by Carlene O’Connor

March 2, 2025February 28, 2025 by CarolNo Comments

I listened to Murder in an Irish Garden on audio and I loved the narrator's accent. She helped place the book solidly in Ireland. And I love hearing names and places pronounced correctly. The story starts off with Siobhan studying for her detective sergeant exam with help from her husband, Macdara. This somehow leads to a fight that has them bickering through the first half of the book, which I found annoying, especially since I couldn't see what the big deal was to begin with. Maybe they always argue? I've only read one other in this series. This time, the mystery centers around a garden competition. One of the competitors is found murdered and everyone's gardens have been ruined. Multiple crime scenes and plenty of suspects make it a complicated case. Everyone seems innocent and and everyone seems guilty. While the plot was good, I also enjoyed all the garden and flower talk. Maybe I'm just dreaming of summer and...