The House of Silk by Anthony Horowitz lived up to its promise. It felt like a true Sherlock Holmes story told by his ever faithful Watson.
The narrative starts at Baker Street when an art dealer arrives unannounced. His name is Edmund Carstairs and he is being menaced by a wanted criminal who seems to have followed him all the way from America. Holmes agrees to investigate, with the help of his Baker Street Irregulars. It’s not long, though, until Holmes and Watson hear of The House of Silk and are drawn into a deeper, deadlier mystery, a conspiracy protected by some of the most powerful men in England.
Sherlock and Watson were the characters I’ve known and loved for years. Watson’s narrative voice is true to the originals, but how much he cared for Holmes really shines through here. He can be a little dull, but he’s loyal and trustworthy. Holmes is his usual brilliant self, complete with his idiosyncrasies, vices, and amazing powers of deduction. The plot is full of twists, turns, and surprising revelations, but I don’t think you have to be a fan of the originals to enjoy this well-crafted mystery. And I do think it had a more modern feel than the original. As Watson says, today’s readers are “more inured to scandal and corruption than [his] own would have been.”
For the Holmes’ fans, Horowitz throws in a variety of well-known characters, including the Baker Street Irregulars, Inspector Lestrade, Mycroft, and even includes a cameo appearance by Moriarty.
I do wish I had read this one instead of listened to the audio. I’ve seen many rave reviews of Derek Jacobi’s reading, and I do think he was a perfect Watson. His narration was full of expression and he did catch the tone of the novel. It was his Holmes voice though that just didn’t sit right with me. I realize that it’s just because I hear him differently in my head, but that’s how it is.
Definitely an enjoyable book, a good addition to the Holmes stories. A must-read for any of Holmes’ adorers.
4 out of 5 stars
Category: Mystery- Historical
Amazon | IndieBound | Website | Twitter
Published November 1, 2011
10 hours 25 minutes
Book source: Library
I’ve got to get to this one soon! It sounds like a lot of fun.
Oh this one sounds great!
I wonder if the Boy Band would like this… or even if he’s still interested. I had to teach him how to navigate the adult stacks in our library a few years back so he could read the original Holmes!
That’s awesome. I think I still have my first book of Holmes stories somewhere in the basement. I should pull it out and see if Amber’s interested.
Nice to hear that he captures the spirit of the books 😀 That is so very important
Thank you…I have heard good things bout this one, too..and that’s why I don’t like audio…
Usually I really like audios. I’d been planning on trying Christie on audio, but I wonder if I’d have the same problem with Poirot.
This sounds very good. I need to read a Holmes book.
That cover is reminding me of something, and I can’t place it.
Great review! Looks like it is the type of book I would love to pick up soon.
Glad to hear that you enjoyed this one and that both the narrator and the new author did a good job.
I would like to read this, thank you!
I have always loved the sounds and ideas of Sherlock Holmes, but never read one of his books. I should read one, one of these days I think. 🙂 Thank you for the review.
I had hoped to read this. I just need to finish the original Conan Doyle series first.