Mystery – Page 2 – Carol's Notebook

The Sittaford Mystery by Agatha Christie

January 6, 2026January 6, 2026 by Carol4 Comments

The Sittaford Mystery is a stand alone that doesn't feature and of Christie's usual characters. The book starts off with a party held in a stately manor in the middle of nowhere during a snow storm. The guests are an interesting mix and they decide to try table-turning, a way of contacting the spirits based on the movements of the table they are all sitting around. The table soon announces that the owner of the house, Captain Trevelyan, who is not present, has been murdered. Everyone assumes it is a joke in very bad taste, but Trevelyan's friend, Major Burnaby, decides he need to walk six miles in the snow to the house Trevelyan is renting, to check on him. Trevelyan has, of course, been murdered. We get a nice mix of amateur and official investigation here. Our amateur sleuth is Emily Trefusis, the fiancée of the man being held for the murder. She is determined and clever. She teams...

The Dog Sitter Detective’s Christmas Tail by Antony Johnston

December 30, 2025December 30, 2025 by CarolNo Comments

The Dog Sitter Detective's Christmas Tail has lots of things I enjoy in a mystery - Christmas, dogs, a snowed-in house full of suspects, but I just didn't really enjoy it. Gwinny is an actress trying to revive her career and is dog-sitting for a bit of money or fostering a dog for no money in this case. She's dating Birch, a retired Detective Chief Inspector who has a black lab. You know from the blurb that the two of them end up snowed in in a house with 6 former spies. One of the spies, their host actually, ends up dead. Gwinny and Birch feel like it's up to them to discover who the killer is. I have not read the others in the series, but this one felt like it worked well enough as a standalone. We get some background on Gwinny and Birch and are told that she's solved a couple of cases in the past, but this...

The Devil in Oxford by Jess Armstrong

December 22, 2025December 22, 2025 by Carol4 Comments

I love the Ruby Vaughan series. The 1920s setting, the characters, the touch of the paranormal, along with well plotted mysteries, keep me engrossed. This time around Ruby and her employer/father-figure, Mr. Owen, are spending the holidays in Oxford at a a meeting of antiquarians. In addition to her duties for Mr. Owen, Ruby is spending time catching up with an old friend, Leona. When local curiosity museum owner Julius Harker doesn’t show up for a planned presentation of Egyptian artifacts and is instead found murdered, Ruby gets pulled into the investigation. Leona, it seems, was close to both Harker and the man arrested for his murder, his business partner Herr Mueller. The mystery was good enough. We have several possible culprits, and since we didn't know a lot of these cast of side characters from the previous books, we don't know who to trust. Ruan is in town too, at Ruby's (written when drunk) invitation, but his support is of course...

The Mistletoe Murder Club by Katie Marsh

December 19, 2025December 19, 2025 by Carol6 Comments

I picked up The Mistletoe Murder Club, knowing it's the fourth book in the series and I haven't read any of the others. I am a sucker for a Christmas mystery and this one looked fun. The author did a good job of giving enough background without over explaining. Clio, Amber, and Jeanie are a fun team, but maybe rely more on luck and guesses than actual investigating. Clio is in a Christmas pantomime directed by the famous actress, Beatrice Butler. Unfortunately, there is tension among the cast members and Beatrice is not a nice person. When she ends up dead it's not surprising, the question is which one of them was angry enough to kill her. Detective Marco Santini is leading the investigation, but of course the women are determined to solve it. We have plenty of suspects and clues and the twist was decent. I'm not sure I'll bother going back and reading others in the series, but this...

Mistletoe Murders 4 by Ken Cuperus

December 16, 2025December 16, 2025 by Carol2 Comments

Emily is back in town, and of course back to solving murders. She's been gone a year and some things have changed - Sam has a new girlfriend, Violet is at college, and some things haven't- like the diner's black coffee. Each audiobook has three separate novellas and each one is fun and has a bit of suspense. The mysteries are (mostly)self-contained but there is an over-arching storyline that deals with Emily's past. We of course end on a cliff-hanger, which I do find annoying. I will listen to the next one - I don't need a cliff-hanger to guarantee it. Actually, by the time next December rolls around, I'll probably need reminded what was going on anyway....

The Holly Village Murders by Benedict Brown

December 9, 2025December 9, 2025 by Carol1 Comment

Poor Bella. Her fiancé was recently killed and now her Aunt Adele is dead under mysterious circumstances. Marius Quin, our mystery novelist/ amateur detective, and Bella head to Holly Village, where Adele lived, to figure out what happened. The folks are an interesting lot, mostly older aristocrats, but it's hard for Marius and Bella to imagine any of them as the killer. Marius and Bella make a good team, although I'm a little tired of Marius' "I love her but can't tell her" bit. The banter between the two is fun and their strengths play off each other well. The mystery takes place over about two days. We get plenty of clues and the whodunnit might be a little obvious, but there are plenty of Christmas touches that make this a nice read for the season. It's well-researched and lets you feel immersed in the late 1920s in London. It's the 6th in the series but was written to be...