Book Reviews – Carol's Notebook

Jay to the World by Donna Andrews

October 23, 2026 by CarolNo Comments

Yes, I might be starting my Christmas reading a little early this year. No, I don't care. Jay to the World is #40 in the Meg Langslow series, but I haven't read even close to all of them. I like that you can jump in and out of the series without feeling like you've missed much. It's almost Christmas in Caerphilly, and we all know that means family, food, and chaos. Meg's mom, Margaret, has a lot going on - family and old friends are in town, she's working on a playhouse for two-year old Brynn, is decorating a room in the annual "Show House." It's all (almost) under control, until Margaret finds the playhouse vandalized and is attacked. It turns out she has several potential enemies in town, and it's up to Meg and the police to keep her safe and figure out who the bad guy is. I like how well Andrews balances the mystery and cozy aspects of...

The Crow Trap by Ann Cleeves

October 22, 2026October 22, 2026 by CarolNo Comments

The Crow Trap was not what I expected. Granted, I've never watched the Vera Stanhope tv series, but I knew it existed, so I expected Vera to be more of a main character here. She doesn't show up until about halfway through the book and it takes even longer for us to see anything from her point of view. The three women at the forefront of the book are working on an environmental study of the area before a quarry is dug. Rachel is the leader, but she is preoccupied with her friend's suicide - and that she's working for her ex who stole credit for her work. The other two women, Anne and Grace, each has her own secrets. We get peeks into their lives and into what brought them here now. It's not "just a job" for any of them. It's complicated and messy and then there's another death, bringing DI Vera Stanhope on the scene. Vera is...

Ordeal by Innocence by Agatha Christie

October 21, 2026October 21, 2026 by Carol2 Comments

It's been a long time since the last time I read Ordeal by Innocence. It's one of Christie's standalones without any of her regular characters. Instead, we have the dysfunctional Argyle family, and Dr. Calgary who has upset their status quo. Jacko Argyle was convicted of killing his mother, despite his claiming to have an alibi, and died in prison. Now, two years later, Dr. Calgary shows up to provide Jacko's solid alibi - first the doctor had had amnesia from an accident, then gone on a research trip to Antarctica, so had been unable to testify at the trial. Now, the case is reopened, and all the "innocent" are under scrutiny again. This is not my favorite of Christie's books. Most of the Argyles are unlikable and we get to spend a lot of time learning about their odd relationships with their adoptive parents and each other. Rachel Argyle, the victim, had opened their home to children during the...

The Chester Grand Murders by Karen Baugh Menuhin

October 20, 2026October 20, 2026 by CarolNo Comments

This time around, Lennox and Swift are called to the Grand Hotel in Chester. Three members of the Grand Proprietors’ Syndicate have recently died, each ruled an accident, but three accidents among ten members is more than suspicious. Lennox and Swift are there usual selves, Swift more practical and by the book, Lennox willing to act bit more on instinct - and to stop for a bite to eat. The whole gang shows up - wives and children and pets to add to the fun and chaos. I appreciate that the secondary characters get full personalities, with secrets and entanglements and plenty of drama. I did figure out the whodunnit and kind of wish the book had gone a different direction, but it all made sense and the clue worked together well....

And Then There Were Bun by Vivien Chien

October 13, 2026October 13, 2026 by CarolNo Comments

I like Lana and her friends and family, but I've never been a huge fan of her detective boyfriend, Adam, and here he's the main suspect in the murder of her ex-boyfriend from college. Adam is suspended while the case is being investigated, which is even more awkward because Megan, Lana's best friend, is dating the chief, Adam's boss. I didn't necessarily love this one. The whole throwback to college people when you're 30 and haven't seen them since forever seems odd. It's weird that the ex even came to the party and Adam's behavior, both losing control during an argument and being so secretive about how he's spending his time recently, seemed out of character. Sometimes I just want characters, and people in real life for that matter, to act like grown ups. The mystery itself was fine. We had plenty of clues and several suspects. I'm not a fan of how quick Lana and Megan can be at jumping to...

Murders in the Marquee by Dana Mentink

October 5, 2026October 5, 2026 by CarolNo Comments

I didn't love Murders in the Marquee. The setting had potential, a fancy hotel in San Francisco in the early 1900s. The ducks, who paraded through the lobby on a daily basis, were cute. The rest of the book was kind of dumb. Our three amateur sleuths, Kitty, a hotel guest, Saul, the man who takes care of the ducks, and Henry, the elevator boy, were an unlikely team, given the era and Kitty's social class. Kitty herself is a bit annoying. Her clearly well-off and all she does is whine. I never really cared about Saul or Henry and felt like their personalities were rather superficial. The mystery was slow. All the clues added up in the end, but they're doled out one at a time and it's like the three have to deal with each clue before they're allowed to have the next. I will say I didn't pay attention to who the publisher was. This would definitely fall...